What Hiring Managers Really Think About Alternative Credentials
- LMSPortals
- Mar 29
- 5 min read
In a job market that’s constantly shifting, traditional degrees no longer hold the monopoly on proving skills. Alternative credentials—bootcamps, online certificates, micro-degrees, industry certifications—are stepping into the spotlight. They’re faster, cheaper, and often more focused on in-demand skills.
But while more people are earning them, a critical question remains: what do hiring managers actually think about alternative credentials?
Are these new pathways truly leveling the playing field, or are they still seen as second-class compared to a college degree? The answer isn’t black and white, but patterns are starting to emerge.
The Rise of Alternative Credentials
Before diving into perceptions, it's important to understand why alternative credentials are gaining traction in the first place.
College tuition has skyrocketed. Student debt in the U.S. now exceeds $1.7 trillion. Meanwhile, the skills employers need—especially in tech, data, and design—are evolving faster than most universities can adapt. As a result, many companies are open to faster, more targeted ways of validating skills.
Bootcamps promise to train someone in 12–24 weeks. Google’s Career Certificates can be completed in under six months. Platforms like LMS Portals give access to industry-taught courses at a fraction of college costs.
For learners, the appeal is obvious. For employers? It’s more complicated.
Credentials vs. Competence
When hiring managers look at a resume, a credential is just one data point. The real question is: Can this person do the job?
Many hiring managers are less concerned with how you learned a skill and more focused on whether you can demonstrate it.
That’s especially true in fields like software engineering, UX design, data analytics, and cybersecurity, where portfolios, projects, and GitHub profiles often matter more than diplomas. In these sectors, alternative credentials can absolutely open doors—if they’re backed by proof of work.
Still, not all hiring managers are sold.
The Trust Gap
Here’s the catch: traditional degrees benefit from brand recognition and perceived rigor. When a hiring manager sees “B.S. in Computer Science from Georgia Tech,” they have a mental model for what that means. With a credential like “Full-Stack Web Development Certificate from XYZ Bootcamp,” that model isn’t always there.
The result? Skepticism.
According to a 2023 report from Northeastern University’s Center for the Future of Higher Education and Talent Strategy, 54% of hiring leaders said alternative credentials made a candidate more attractive if accompanied by work experience. But only 16% said they’d hire someone based on an alternative credential alone.
In other words, these credentials can boost your profile—but they rarely stand on their own.
What Hiring Managers Say (and What They Really Mean)
Let’s break down some common perspectives hiring managers have on alternative credentials, based on interviews, surveys, and industry insights.
1. “We’re open to them—if they show results.”
Translation: If you went through a bootcamp or took a certificate course, we want to see what you did with it. Projects, freelance work, internships, or even personal apps or sites carry weight. Just completing a course isn’t enough.
Hiring managers want evidence of applied learning.
2. “There’s too much variability.”
Translation: Some bootcamps are rigorous and selective. Others take anyone with a credit card. Hiring managers often can’t tell the difference, which leads to hesitation.
This is where reputation matters. Programs that partner with employers, publish placement rates, or have visible alumni networks tend to earn more trust.
3. “We still prefer degrees for leadership roles.”
Translation: Alternative credentials may get your foot in the door for entry-level or junior positions, but many companies still expect a degree for promotions or higher responsibility—especially in larger or more traditional organizations.
This isn’t always about skill. Sometimes it’s about perception, pedigree, or internal policies.
4. “They show initiative.”
Translation: Even if the credential isn’t the deciding factor, it signals that a candidate is motivated to learn and grow. That’s a good sign—especially for career switchers or people re-entering the workforce.
This is often where alternative credentials shine: as part of a larger narrative about someone’s drive, curiosity, and resilience.
Fields Where Alternative Credentials Work Best
Alternative credentials aren’t equally valued in every field. Here’s where they have the most traction:
Tech & Programming: Bootcamps and certifications (e.g., AWS, Google Cloud, CompTIA) are widely accepted if candidates can demonstrate coding ability.
Design: UX/UI certificates, design bootcamps, and strong portfolios can outweigh degrees.
Data Science & Analytics: Certificates from Coursera, edX, or DataCamp, paired with projects, often carry weight.
Digital Marketing: Google Ads, HubSpot, and Meta certifications are recognized and respected in many marketing departments.
Cybersecurity: Certifications like CISSP, Security+, and CEH are often preferred over degrees.
In contrast, in fields like law, medicine, finance, or academia, degrees are still non-negotiable. Alternative credentials may help, but they won’t replace formal education.
The Employer Perspective: A Mixed Bag
Some companies, especially in tech, have fully embraced skills-based hiring. Google, IBM, and Accenture have dropped degree requirements for many roles. They actively recruit from bootcamps and certificate programs.
Others are still catching up. Many HR systems filter out resumes without a degree by default. Some hiring managers default to the familiar. There’s institutional inertia.
But this is slowly changing. According to LinkedIn’s 2023 Future of Skills report, 73% of hiring professionals say they’re more focused on skills than degrees than they were five years ago. Skills-first hiring is gaining traction—even if it’s not yet the norm.
What Candidates Should Know
If you’re pursuing an alternative credential, here’s what hiring managers wish you knew:
Don’t treat the credential as a magic key. It’s a starting point, not the destination. Use it to build real-world projects, collaborate, and gain experience.
Context matters. If you’re switching careers, explain your journey. Tell a story. Hiring managers love a compelling career pivot—especially one backed by hustle.
Know the lingo. Speak the language of the job. Tailor your resume. Highlight skills, tools, and outcomes. Don't just say "completed course on SQL"—say "built a dashboard using SQL and Tableau to analyze customer churn."
Leverage social proof. Recommendations on LinkedIn, testimonials from clients or collaborators, and visible work (like a portfolio or GitHub) build credibility.
Target companies that value nontraditional paths. Some employers are more open than others. Do your research. Look for companies that highlight skills-first hiring in their job descriptions or have alumni from bootcamps.
The Bottom Line
Hiring managers are warming up to alternative credentials—but with caveats. They want proof of competence, not just completion. They want to see initiative, not just enrollment. And they often want experience, even if it’s self-driven.
Alternative credentials can absolutely be part of a successful career path—but only if they’re used strategically. As one recruiter put it, “A certificate tells me you’re interested. Your work tells me you’re ready.”
In the end, skills still matter more than titles. But how you prove those skills—that’s where the game is won or lost.
About LMS Portals
At LMS Portals, we provide our clients and partners with a mobile-responsive, SaaS-based, multi-tenant learning management system that allows you to launch a dedicated training environment (a portal) for each of your unique audiences.
The system includes built-in, SCORM-compliant rapid course development software that provides a drag and drop engine to enable most anyone to build engaging courses quickly and easily.
We also offer a complete library of ready-made courses, covering most every aspect of corporate training and employee development.
If you choose to, you can create Learning Paths to deliver courses in a logical progression and add structure to your training program. The system also supports Virtual Instructor-Led Training (VILT) and provides tools for social learning.
Together, these features make LMS Portals the ideal SaaS-based eLearning platform for our clients and our Reseller partners.
Contact us today to get started or visit our Partner Program pages
Comments