When HR Goes It Alone: The Pitfalls of Siloed Talent Development

Talent development isn’t just an HR function. It’s a business strategy. Yet in many organizations, it’s treated as a standalone effort, owned and operated by HR with little input from leadership or other departments. That isolation—however unintentional—can kill effectiveness, waste resources, and alienate the very people it’s meant to help.

Let’s unpack why siloed talent development doesn’t work, what it costs companies, and how to fix it.

Learn About Our White Label Multi-Tenant SaaS LMS Partnership Program

The Problem with Siloed Talent Development

When HR designs and delivers learning and development (L&D) programs without cross-functional involvement, a few predictable issues emerge:

1. Misaligned Priorities

HR may set up training around soft skills, compliance, or generic leadership models. Meanwhile, department heads are struggling to find employees with deep technical capabilities or future-ready skills. When there’s a disconnect between what’s taught and what the business needs, talent development becomes a check-the-box activity rather than a growth engine.

2. Poor Buy-In

If managers and employees see development initiatives as “HR’s thing,” they’re less likely to engage. People need to understand how training connects to their daily work and long-term goals. Without leadership endorsement or team-level integration, even the best programs fall flat.

3. Resource Waste

Time, money, and energy go into planning and running learning initiatives. But without a clear sense of what success looks like—or how it maps to business outcomes—those investments often go unmeasured and under-leveraged.

4. Talent Drain

Employees want growth. If they don’t see real development opportunities tied to career advancement, they’ll go somewhere else. HR alone can’t build a compelling development culture. That takes shared ownership across the business.

Why This Keeps Happening

HR teams usually don’t silo themselves on purpose. But several common forces push them in that direction:

• Lack of executive sponsorship. If the C-suite sees talent development as peripheral, HR is left to run it solo.

• Overburdened managers. Leaders may agree in principle but feel they don’t have time to participate.

• No clear accountability. When development isn’t tied to performance metrics, it floats untethered.

• One-size-fits-all thinking. Generic programs are easier to scale, but they rarely meet the specific needs of business units.

What It Costs the Business

Siloed talent development isn't just inefficient—it’s a liability. Here's how the costs stack up:

1. Skill Gaps Persist

When HR can’t keep up with evolving technical or strategic demands, critical roles remain underfilled or poorly staffed. That slows productivity and innovation.

2. Engagement Drops

Employees feel disengaged when development feels irrelevant or performative. Gallup research shows that opportunities to learn and grow are among the top drivers of employee engagement. If those are missing—or poorly executed—morale suffers.

3. Internal Mobility Slows

Without coordinated succession planning and cross-functional visibility, high-potential employees stay stuck. This forces companies to look externally for talent they could have grown internally.

4. Strategy Suffers

Ultimately, business goals depend on people. When workforce capability doesn’t evolve with strategy, the company lags behind competitors.

What Better Looks Like

Solving this isn’t about HR doing more. It’s about HR doing less alone.

1. Make Talent Development a Leadership Priority

Executives need to champion development as a key lever of business success. That means:

• Talking about it in strategy meetings

• Tying development metrics to business KPIs

• Holding managers accountable for team growth

When development becomes part of the company’s language of success, it stops being “just an HR thing.”

2. Collaborate with Department Leaders

Great development programs are built with the business, not just for it. That means HR needs to:

• Co-create learning paths with department heads

• Ask what skills are missing, not just what’s easy to teach

• Include line managers in talent reviews, succession planning, and career pathing

This ensures learning aligns with actual job demands and growth opportunities.

3. Empower Managers as Coaches

Managers shouldn’t just delegate learning to HR. They should own it in their teams. That involves:

• Giving regular feedback and development conversations

• Supporting stretch assignments and job rotations

• Tracking growth over time—not just in annual reviews

HR can provide the tools and frameworks, but managers drive the day-to-day impact.

4. Involve Employees in Their Own Development

Development works best when employees have agency. Instead of assigning mandatory courses, companies should:

• Offer choice and flexibility in learning options

• Make growth visible and measurable (career frameworks, skill maps, etc.)

• Reward initiative, curiosity, and learning agility

This shifts development from a top-down mandate to a shared journey.

5. Use Data to Drive Strategy

Data helps break silos by creating shared visibility. HR should work with finance, operations, and analytics teams to:

• Track development outcomes tied to business metrics

• Identify skill gaps through workforce analytics

• Monitor internal mobility, promotion rates, and retention of high-potentials

Shared data builds shared accountability.

A Real-World Example

Let’s say a software company is trying to shift to a cloud-first model. HR rolls out a series of online training modules on cloud computing fundamentals. But engineering leaders complain that the content is too high-level and doesn’t help their teams transition actual products.

Here’s what a non-siloed approach could look like:

1. HR meets with engineering leads to understand where the skill gaps are (e.g., cloud architecture, containerization).

2. Together, they build a development pathway that includes vendor certifications, internal tech talks, and mentoring from cloud-experienced staff.

3. Managers are trained to reinforce learning through projects and peer reviews.

4. HR tracks who completes the path and partners with workforce planning to identify internal candidates for cloud-related roles.

5. Executives talk about the initiative as part of the company’s transformation strategy.

This creates alignment across strategy, capability, and execution. And it delivers measurable ROI.

The Role of HR—Reframed

HR doesn’t lose relevance in this model—it gains it. Instead of acting as the sole driver of development, HR becomes:

• A facilitator of cross-functional collaboration

• A consultant to managers on how to grow their teams

• A curator of learning resources tailored to business needs

• A strategic advisor using talent data to inform decisions

That’s a more empowered, respected, and effective HR function.

Signs You’re Operating in a Silo

Want to know if your talent development is too isolated? Look for these red flags:

• Low participation in L&D programs outside HR-led campaigns

• Managers unsure how to support development beyond annual reviews

• Training content that doesn’t reflect current business goals

• Employees unclear on how to grow in their roles

• No link between development efforts and performance outcomes

If any of those ring true, it’s time to build bridges.

Moving Forward: From Silo to Strategy

Breaking down the walls around talent development doesn’t require a massive overhaul. It starts with intentional collaboration.

Here are three practical first steps:

1. Host a cross-functional talent review. Bring together HR, department heads, and senior leaders to map current capabilities, identify skill gaps, and align on growth priorities.

2. Audit your existing programs. Ask: Do they match what the business actually needs? Who's involved in shaping them? Who's accountable for results?

3. Start small with shared pilots. Choose one department or initiative, partner closely, and build a joint development plan. Use it as a model for others.

Done right, talent development becomes everyone’s responsibility—and everyone’s opportunity.

Summary

When HR goes it alone, talent development often falls short. But when it’s co-owned across the business, it becomes a powerful engine for growth, engagement, and competitive advantage. The future of learning isn’t in silos. It’s in sync.

About LMS Portals

At LMS Portals, we provide our clients and partners with a mobile-responsive, SaaS-based, multi-tenant learning management system that allows you to launch a dedicated training environment (a portal) for each of your unique audiences.

The system includes built-in, SCORM-compliant rapid course development software that provides a drag and drop engine to enable most anyone to build engaging courses quickly and easily. 

We also offer a complete library of ready-made courses, covering most every aspect of corporate training and employee development.

If you choose to, you can create Learning Paths to deliver courses in a logical progression and add structure to your training program.  The system also supports Virtual Instructor-Led Training (VILT) and provides tools for social learning.

Together, these features make LMS Portals the ideal SaaS-based eLearning platform for our clients and our Reseller partners.

Contact us today to get started or visit our Partner Program pages